Who Decided the Beginner Should Keep Quiet?

Published on 19 November 2026 at 18:44

The new person gets to the bottom of the form and puts a finger between the two boxes.

“Why do we need two signatures?”

Someone stops clicking their pen. The person running the meeting looks down at the page. For one full second, the only sound is a cup being put back on its saucer.

And two seats away, the woman who knows this process better than anyone is thinking, Damn. I wish I’d asked that.

She knows who signs first. She knows who can sign when that person is away. She knows that if you need it done on a Friday, you’d better bring the form before lunch. She’s probably taught half the room how to get it through.

Somewhere between learning the procedure and teaching it, asking what it was for started to feel like admitting something.

That’s the part I find interesting. When you’ve been there a week, “Why?” is a perfectly ordinary question. When you’ve trained half the room, you can already hear the question that might come back.

You’ve been doing this for twelve years and you’re asking now?

So somebody says, “We’ve always done it that way.”

Thank you. We now know how long we’ve been doing it.

I like to imagine what happens if the woman two seats away says what she’s actually thinking.

“I’ve wondered about that too. I can tell you exactly who signs it. Give me a minute to remember why.”

Maybe the second person is looking for a different mistake. In that case, tell the new person what to look for. It’ll be the most useful thing they learn about that form. Or maybe the second signature dates back to when two offices kept separate records. In that case, I’d quite like to know who still needs it. Especially on a Friday.

I think the most interesting bit of leadership in that room belongs to whoever can say, in front of people they’ve trained, “Now that you mention it, I’d like an answer too.” The beginner has already asked the question. That person has enough experience to make sure it gets answered.

At the next meeting, I’d like to sit beside the woman who knows the form by heart. I have a feeling she’s got a list.

Silvia

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.